If you want an authentic Louisiana gumbo experience, gumbo filé powder plays a unique role. Made from dried, ground sassafras leaves, filé adds both thickening power and a distinctive earthy, tea-like flavor that is closely associated with Creole and Cajun cooking.
The problem is availability. Gumbo filé is not always easy to find outside Louisiana or specialty spice shops. Fortunately, gumbo has a long history of adaptation, and there are traditional and practical alternatives that can replace filé’s thickening role, its flavor contribution, or both.
Last update on 2026-02-01. We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
Your Best Bet: Okra
Traditional gumbo relies on one of two classic thickeners: gumbo filé powder or okra. Many food historians argue that okra is the older of the two, tracing gumbo’s roots to West African cuisine where okra was a staple ingredient.
In Louisiana, seasonal availability likely dictated which thickener was used. Fresh okra was more common in warmer months, while filé powder, made from dried leaves, was used in cooler seasons. As a result, okra gumbo is often associated with summer cooking, while filé gumbo is linked to winter.
Okra thickens dishes through a soluble fiber called mucilage, which gives okra its characteristic slippery texture. When cooked properly, this mucilage blends smoothly into the broth and creates body without overpowering the dish.
There is no fixed ratio for substituting okra for filé powder. Add sliced or chopped okra gradually until you reach your preferred thickness. Flavor-wise, okra is much milder than filé and does not provide the same herbal notes, making it primarily a textural substitute rather than a flavor match.
A Decent Second Choice: Roux
Roux is another cornerstone of Cajun and Creole cooking and is frequently used as a gumbo thickener, either alone or alongside okra or filé. It is made by cooking flour in fat until it reaches a desired color, ranging from pale blond to deep brown.
In gumbo, a medium to dark brown roux is most common. This type of roux contributes nutty, toasted flavors and a deep reddish-brown color that is iconic in many Louisiana gumbos.
Unlike filé powder, roux thickens through starch gelatinization rather than mucilage. It also adds richness and depth but lacks filé’s herbal, slightly astringent finish.
While it is technically possible to use roux, okra, and filé together, doing so is generally considered non-traditional and can result in an overly thick dish.
In A Pinch: Cornstarch
Corn starch is a neutral, refined thickener made from the endosperm of corn kernels. While it has no traditional connection to gumbo, it can effectively replace filé’s thickening role when other options are unavailable.
To use corn starch, create a slurry by mixing it with cold water, then stir it into the gumbo near the end of cooking. Corn starch thickens quickly and should not be boiled for extended periods, or it may lose effectiveness.
Because corn starch does not add flavor, it can slightly mute the dish’s overall profile. Compensate by increasing spices, aromatics, or smoked ingredients to maintain balance.
Sassafras Leaf Tea Or Ground Leaves
Since gumbo filé is made from sassafras leaves, using whole dried leaves or a brewed sassafras leaf tea can partially replicate its flavor. While this method does not provide the same thickening strength as powdered filé, it can add some of the distinct herbal notes associated with filé gumbo.
This option works best when combined with another thickener such as roux or okra. Use sparingly, as sassafras flavor can become bitter if overused.
Arrowroot Powder
Arrowroot is a starch derived from tropical tubers and is often used as a gluten-free thickener. It produces a clear, glossy texture similar to corn starch but holds up slightly better to acidity.
Like corn starch, arrowroot has no traditional flavor connection to gumbo, but it works well when texture is the primary concern. Add it at the end of cooking and avoid prolonged boiling.
Okra Powder
Dried, ground okra powder is an increasingly popular pantry item. It provides both okra’s thickening properties and mild vegetal flavor without introducing fresh okra’s texture.
This option works well for cooks who dislike okra’s mouthfeel but still want a more traditional gumbo thickener than cornstarch. Use it gradually, as it thickens more subtly than filé powder.
Xanthan Gum (Modern Alternative)
Xanthan gum is a powerful modern thickener that requires only a tiny amount. While completely non-traditional, it can be useful in small quantities when texture control is critical.
Because xanthan gum lacks flavor and cultural relevance, it should only be used as a last resort and never as a one-to-one substitute for filé powder.
Other Alternatives
Some cooks experiment with root beer or sassafras-flavored beverages to mimic filé’s aromatic notes. While these liquids can add a hint of flavor, they provide no thickening and should only be used alongside a starch-based thickener such as roux or corn starch.
This approach is unconventional but highlights how gumbo’s flavor profile has inspired creative substitutions over time.
Quick Facts & Pairing Summary
| Substitute | Thickening Power | Flavor Contribution | Best Use Case |
|---|---|---|---|
| Okra | High | Mild, vegetal | Traditional summer gumbo |
| Roux | High | Nutty, toasted | Cajun and Creole gumbos |
| Corn starch | High | Neutral | Quick thickening |
| Sassafras leaves/tea | Low | Herbal, earthy | Flavor support |
| Arrowroot | Medium | Neutral | Gluten-free thickening |
| Okra powder | Medium | Mild okra flavor | Texture without slime |
| Xanthan gum | Very high | None | Emergency texture fix |
Summing It Up
Gumbo filé powder is unique, but it is not irreplaceable. Okra and roux remain the most traditional and effective substitutes, while starches like corn starch and arrowroot provide functional alternatives when needed. Flavor-focused options such as sassafras leaves can help bridge the gap, especially when used alongside a proper thickener.
Choosing the right substitute depends on whether your priority is authenticity, texture, or convenience, all of which gumbo has balanced for generations.
Related Reading
- What’s A Good Sassafras Substitute? In the need for a solution to this unique flavor? Try these.
- Arrowroot Vs. Corn Starch: Learn how these two thickeners compare.
- Sassafras Vs. Saffron: Similar names, but how similar are these spices really?